Author: Samuel Ackerman
For someone’s engagement with politics and civic affairs to be beneficial for society, they must view themselves as part of many larger communities. They must also assess and reflect on critical issues facing these communities and act to address them when necessary. Meeting the standard of engaging in constructive civic engagement is not a simple task, as it requires us to view the world in a way that may not be intuitive, since humans are considered to be inherently selfish creatures.
People have many reasons for caring about certain causes or voting the way they do. One of the main drivers of these thoughts and actions is fear. Fear of the unknown. Fear of the future. Fear that other groups are receiving preferential treatment. Fear that they have been or will be left behind. When people are scared of what the future may bring, a promise to return to a past “golden era” is an attractive proposition. This fear often leads to anger, which politicians, interest groups, or foreign influence operations can redirect towards a scapegoat.
Social media spreads and amplifies this fear and anger, in part because its algorithms often promote controversial and divisive views due to the high levels of engagement they receive. The influence of social media on politics across the world continues to grow, and while it has given people a tool to fight for equality, human rights, and democracy, it can also accelerate democratic decay.
It is much easier to selfishly contribute to the divisiveness online than to act in the public interest, especially when a certain issue does not affect someone personally. Furthermore, social media and other forms of online media have increasingly desensitized us to hate and violence, likely making us less likely to care about humanitarian issues enough to act.
People can become so stuck within their social media bubble that they are hardly living in reality anymore. While posting about politics on social media is technically a form of civic participation, it likely does not reach the level of political engagement that the French philosopher Alexis de Tocqueville argued was required to preserve democracy.
A strong civic society leads to the expansion of civil rights, a growth of social trust, or greater cooperation between communities. Civic engagement driven by fear, anger, and hate brings about the opposite: a society where people are distrustful of institutions and their neighbors. Humans are inherently social, but instead of getting to know those who are different than us through civil dialogue, many Americans choose to isolate themselves and fight a populist culture war that distracts them from the real issues. This phenomenon is not isolated to the United States, as many countries across the globe are also susceptible to shifts away from a positive and robust public discourse.
Civic engagement helps people see the humanity in others, even when they disagree about how to achieve a political objective. A high degree of positive civic engagement is necessary for democracy to thrive, and a society where people distrust institutions and their neighbors lacks trust and constructive dialogue. The future is inevitable, and humanity's course must be plotted by countless different communities across many countries working together and not through reactionary policy built on fear and anger.
References
Blaug, Ricardo, and John Schwarzmantel. Democracy: A Reader. Columbia University Press, 2016.
The New York Times. “The Definition of Civic Engagement.” The New York Times, July 7, 2003. https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/ref/college/collegespecial2-/coll_aascu_defi.html.